Lenolandia: El mundo de la Sra. Lenord
  • Home
  • Blog
  • Resources
  • Gallery
  • Presentations
  • About Amy

Perfection and the Idea of Audience

11/19/2014

1 Comment

 
Somebody stop me... I am staying up on the soapbox a little longer.

This perfection thing won't get out of my head. It's like a bad song that keeps playing over and over again. 

Because this topic seems to resonate with educators out there, I keep getting messages and comments encouraging me for sharing, and those messages reminded me of something else one of those honor students said to me a few weeks ago. She said,

"I know we should, but we don't have time to really learn anything."

This statement just kills me, especially because I remember a time when I was that teacher who would fall over the deep end and hand my student lists with dozens and dozens of vocabulary or verbs to memorize. I would then design assessments that would target the most irregular or obscure items on those lists thinking that I was doing them a favor by forcing them to learn the hardest content and allowing for the easier content to take care of itself. I took points off for missing accents, spelling errors, and not using the word I would in a given context. ME, I did that. So, today a question that is plaguing me is, what does it mean to learn in the language classroom?


One of the tenets of our beloved ACTFL Proficiency Guidelines is the idea of a sympathetic reader / listener. This is not just due to the learning environment we intend to create in our language classrooms, but because in the real world any reader or listener who is interacting with a second language learner will strive to not only understand the new speaker, but will oftentimes try to help him get his point across by suggesting words as they struggle to communicate. I KNOW this is true, because I live this action research every day. I am not a superior level speaker like some of my colleagues and they are always guiding me, compensating for me and teaching me new things so that the communication doesn't fall apart. So, if this is true for me, it will be true for our students when they embark upon communicating with others outside of our classroom walls.

Having said that, let me shift back to my earlier question: what does it mean to learn something in the language classroom? Doesn't it really mean that we know something well enough to employ it later? We have to ask ourselves, "what do we really want as a result of our instruction?" Do we want perfection from our students in the minutia of the language or do we want them to communicate? If we want them to communicate, then what need is there to attain 100% accuracy? Can we be THAT accurate ourselves?  English is my first language, and while I would like to consider myself a superior level communicator in this language, I know that some of you read what I write and find mistakes in my posts. I find them all the time. Do the mitsakes I make in my writing make the points I write about less relevant? Do they confuse my audience? Probably not at all.

How about this idea, shouldn't we do more than just be the perfection police?

This is really where the idea of coaching rather than teaching makes sense to me. If we are doing right by our students, we are building their confidence in their own ability. one of the abilities we are training is the ability to be understood by others, so we have to give our students as many opportunities to speak and write for an audience that is not us. The reason this is so important is because their audience doesn't have the same agenda we (the teachers) have. They really only want to know what the student has to say, not so much how well they say it. Plus, our students need to know what it feels like to NOT be understood so they can learn to be aware of their communication or lack thereof, compensate,  and find another way to communicate their message. It is precisely the moment that the intended message misses its mark that our students become interested in accuracy, and not before.  Plus, our correction, which is really a misplaced need to control the situation, becomes unnecessary. If we do things right our students will make mistakes, realize it, then need us to answer their questions about how to be better understood. So in effect, audience is everything. Well, almost everything. We have to be smart enough to find that sweet spot instructionally where students are practicing just a hair out of their comfort zone so that they will have to make mistakes, inquire and adjust. What is amazing is that our students are able to bounce back from mistakes in the moment so much better when they find them on their own instead of when we find them. Sometimes the things we find wrong have nothing to do with whether they were understood or not, #controlfreaks. Our corrections do lead to making students continually second guess themselves, so we must stop. Would a coach want his quarterback paralyzed with indecision?

Happy Coaching, friends!
1 Comment
James Yoder
11/19/2014 06:15:46 am

Bravo on another excellent post! I think I told you about the "rigorous" teacher I observed once who jumped all over her kids anytime they made an error that everything they said in class sounded like a question.

"Mi clase fav fav ¿fa vo ri ta? ¿es? ¿historia?"

If one of them dared to say favorito, she immediately corrected them by saying (in a sort annoyed and condescending voice) "¡¡¡favoritA!!!! Mi clase favorita..."

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Lenolandia:

    (n.) A special place where we remember that students are humans that need to feel loved and important, where their achievements are celebrated every day and where we learn Spanish along the way!

    My Blogging Tribe

    Musicuentos 
    ​by Sara-Elizabeth Cottrell
    El mundo de Birch
    by Sharon Birch
    PBLintheTL
    ​
    by Laura Sexton
    Kristy Placido's Blog
    by Kristy Placido
    Language Sensei
    by Colleen Lee-Hayes

    Creative Language Class
    ​
    by Kara Parker &
    Megan Smith
    Somewhere to Share
    by Carrie Toth
    ​
    En Francais, SVP!
    by Wendy Farabaugh
    ​Super Spanish Senora
    by Talia Block
    Tales from the Salle de Clase
    by Megan Sulewski
    ​Que sera, sera
    by Amanda Diaz Mora
    Thinking About Syncing?
    ​by Catherine Ousselin
    Path to Proficiency
    Craig Talks Teaching

    by Craig McKinney

    Subscribe

    Enter your email address:

    Delivered by FeedBurner

    Categories

    All
    90% Target Language
    90% Target Language
    ACTFL
    Activation
    Advocacy
    Apps
    Assessment
    Audio
    Authentic Resources
    Authentic Resources
    Authres
    Balance
    Blogging
    BTS
    Building Proficiency
    Building Relationships
    Building Trust
    Burnout
    BYOD
    Challenges
    CI
    Classroom Environment
    Collaboration
    Collaborations
    Communication
    Communities
    Comprehensible Input
    Conflict
    Conversation
    Creating With The Language
    Culture
    Curation
    Daily Driving Questions
    Digital
    Drawing Attention
    During Reading Strategies
    Edtech
    Elaboration
    Encouragement
    Failure
    Feedback
    Focus Questions
    Goals
    Google Classroom
    Grading
    Grammar
    Graphic Organizers
    Increasing Proficiency
    Independent Learning
    Input
    Inquiry
    Inspiration
    Instruction
    Interacting With Text
    Interpersonal
    Interpersonal Practice
    IP Blitz
    Know Thyself
    Language Acquisition
    Language Methods
    Language Proficiency
    Language Teaching
    Language Teaching
    Learner Training
    Lenord's Lessons
    Lesson Design
    Lifelong Learners
    Listening
    Making Meaning
    Meaning Vs. Form
    Mentoring
    Metacognition
    Momentum
    Multi-level
    Music
    Negotiating Tenses
    Networking
    New Year
    Novice Learners
    #OneWord
    Online Presence
    Online Presence
    Output
    Paradigm Change
    PBL
    Performance Based
    Personal Growth
    Personalize
    Personalizing Language
    Planning
    Pln
    Politics
    Powerpoints
    Pre-speaking
    Preterite Vs. Imperfect
    Primacy/Recency
    Prior Knowledge
    Processing
    Professional Development
    Professional Learning
    Professional Organizations
    Questions
    Quizlet
    Reading
    Reflection
    Relationships
    Resolutions
    Scaffolding
    Self Protection
    Self Selected Vocabulary
    Self-selected Vocabulary
    Speaking Practice
    Spontaneous Conversation
    State Organizations
    Strategies
    Structured Input
    Structured Output
    Student Centered
    Support
    Survival Strategies
    Taking Care
    TALK READ TALK WRITE
    Target Language Teaching
    #Teach2Teach
    Teacher As Facilitator
    Teaching
    Teaching Challenges
    Teaching Tools
    Team Building
    Technology
    TELL Collab
    Tenses
    Textbooks
    Text Type
    The 10%
    Time Management
    TL Reading
    TLT
    TPRS
    Training Learners
    Transition
    TRTW
    Verb Charts
    Verbs
    Vocabulary
    Vocabulary Instruction
    Vocabulary Processing
    Weebly
    What I Would Do - Ideas For Authentic Resources
    Workload
    Worksheets

    Archives

    April 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    August 2018
    January 2018
    November 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    January 2017
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.
Photos used under Creative Commons from wit, Јerry, Festival Gastronómico, davecito, swong95765, symphony of love, john581, One Way Stock, mirandamylne1992, GabboT, usacetulsa, katerha, Infomastern, STC4blues, GerryT, IQRemix, StockMonkeys.com, Andy Hay, Tambako the Jaguar, CollegeDegrees360, tfbpereira, Janitors, Experiencia Colombia, One Way Stock, jakeliefer, katerha, gobzoro, MICOLO J Thanx 4 1.4 mill+ views, Mr Conguito, Dusty J, Elsa Blaine, foilman, frankieleon, Wiertz Sébastien, Kevan
  • Home
  • Blog
  • Resources
  • Gallery
  • Presentations
  • About Amy